ee-tark-tee_d2-srti

Catalogue Record

catalogue-record:
    table:
        evaluation_metadata:
            content_provider_contact:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: ''
                evaluation: '-'
                data: chmylonas@certh.gr
                is_implied: ''
                comment: ''
            evaluated_dataset_url:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: ''
                evaluation: '-'
                data: https://tarktee.ee/#/en/datex
                is_implied: ''
                comment: ''
            evaluation_date:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: ''
                evaluation: '-'
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: ''
            evaluator:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: ''
                evaluation: '-'
                data: Chrysostomos Mylonas
                is_implied: ''
                comment: ''
        metadata_information:
            metadata_date:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.1.1
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            metadata_language:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.1.2
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: C
                data: est; eng; rus
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Implied by switching languages in the metadata page
            contact_point:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.1.3
                obligation: partially*
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            dataset_identifier:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
        content_information:
            name_of_the_dataset:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.2.1
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: A
                data: Important road safety data
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Provided as expected
            description_of_dataset:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.2.2
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: B
                data: Important road safety data
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Description is the same with the name of the dataset
            resource_type:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.2.3
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: C
                data: dataset
                is_implied: 'yes'
                comment: Assumed
            dataset_type_category:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.2.4
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            dataset_detailed_type:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.2.5
                obligation: optional
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            service_type_category:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.2.6
                obligation: conditionally*
                evaluation: '-'
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Non applicable
            dataset_language:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.2.7
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: C
                data: eng
                is_implied: 'yes'
                comment: Implied by the sample data
            georeferencing_method:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.2.8
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: C
                data: linearWithinLinearElement, pointAlongLinearElement, pointByCoordinates
                is_implied: 'yes'
                comment: Implied by the sample data
            dataset_documentation:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: A
                data: https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/DATEX_II_Estonian_profile_Tark_Tee.pdf
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            related_linked_data_sources:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
        temporal_information:
            start_date_of_publication:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.3.1
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            end_date_of_publication:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.3.2
                obligation: optional
                evaluation: '-'
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Non applicable
        geographical_coverage:
            area_covered_by_publication:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.4.1
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: C
                data: Estonia (EE0)
                is_implied: 'yes'
                comment: Implied by the jurisdinction of the data provider
            network_coverage:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.4.2
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: C
                data: National road network
                is_implied: 'yes'
                comment: Implied by dataset title and description
            network_coverage_description:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.4.3
                obligation: optional
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
        transportation_system:
            transportation_modes_covered:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.5.1
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: C
                data: Motorized traffic
                is_implied: 'yes'
                comment: Implied by dataset title and description
        responsibilities:
            publisher:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.6.1
                obligation: partially*
                evaluation: B
                data: Estonian Transport Administration
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not in the expected format (contact info is not available)
            data_owner:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.6.2
                obligation: partially*
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
        conditions_for_use:
            contract_or_license:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.7.1
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            conditions_for_use:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.7.2
                obligation: conditionally*
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
        access_information:
            data_format__encoding:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.8.1
                obligation: optional
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            data_format__syntax:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.8.2
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: C
                data: XML
                is_implied: 'yes'
                comment: Implied by the sample data
            data_format__grammar:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.8.3
                obligation: optional
                evaluation: C
                data: XSD
                is_implied: 'yes'
                comment: Implied by Syntax
            data_format__data_model:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.8.4
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: A
                data: DATEX II
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Provided as expected
            data_sample:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: A
                data: https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/datex2_ee_mnt_safety_related_example.xml
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Provided as expected
            data_schema__validation:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: A
                data: https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/datex2_ee_mnt_safety_data.xsd
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Provided as expected
            data_format_description:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.8.5
                obligation: conditionally*
                evaluation: A
                data: DATEX II v2.3
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Provided as expected
            access_interface:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.8.6
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: B
                data: HTTP/HTTPS
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not in the expected format (not explicitly mentioned)
            security_mechanisms:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            communication_method:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.8.7
                obligation: conditionally*
                evaluation: C
                data: Pull
                is_implied: 'yes'
                comment: Implied by access URL
            protocol_documentation:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: B
                data: https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/DATEX_II_Estonian_profile_Tark_Tee.pdf
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Does not directly document the protocol
            access_url:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.8.8
                obligation: conditionally*
                evaluation: A
                data: https://tarktee.ee/api/v1/datex/safetyData
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Provided as expected
        quality_information:
            update_frequency:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.9.1
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Mentioned within the documentation
            availability:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            data_collection_method:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            cross_verification:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            problem_reporting_process:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            reaction_time_to_respond:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            quality_description:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.9.2
                obligation: mandatory
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            national_body_assessment_status:
                cmc_ref: 2.2.9.3
                obligation: optional
                evaluation: F
                data: ''
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Not available
            applicable_drs:
                cmc_ref: ''
                obligation: recommended
                evaluation: A
                data: Delegated Regulation (EU) No 886/2013
                is_implied: ''
                comment: Provided as expected
    overall_quality:
        grade: C
        score: 2.873
        evaluation: TODO
    this:
        author: Chrysostomos Mylonas
        created: ''
        modified: null
    pkey_nap: tarktee.ee
    pkey_subid: ee-tark-tee_d2-srti
    publisher: ee-tark-tee
    distribution: d2-srti
    excel_id: EE01
    in_euroroast: null

This page shows metadata about a distribution found in given catalogue record and evaluates it’s formal quality.

Evaluated catalogue record URL

https://tarktee.ee/#/en/datex

Distribution

Publisher > ee-tark-tee > Distribution > d2-srti

Data Access URL

https://tarktee.ee/api/v1/datex/safetyData

Data Format Model

DATEX II

Protocol

Pull

Area covered

Estonia (EE0)

Scope of catalogue record formal quality evaluation

Distribution provides real data to consume.

A Catalogue Record informs about existence of such Distribution.

Following formal quality evaluation deals only with content of the Catalogue Record (as published in NAP catalogue) and not with actual content provided by the Distribution.

For methodology see Methodology for formal quality.

Overall Quality

Grade
C
Score

2.873

Evaluation

TODO

Category-Specific Evaluations

Evaluation Metadata
Grade Parameter Value
- Evaluated Dataset URL 1 https://tarktee.ee/#/en/datex 2
- Evaluation Date 3 4
- Evaluator 5 Chrysostomos Mylonas 6
Grade Parameter Value
F Metadata Date 7 8
C Metadata Language 9 est; eng; rus 10
F Contact Point 11 12
F Dataset Identifier 13 14
Grade Parameter Value
A Name of the Dataset 15 Important road safety data 16
B Description of Dataset 17 Important road safety data 18
C Resource Type 19 dataset 20
F Dataset Type Category 21 22
F Dataset Detailed Type 23 24
- Service Type Category 25 26
C Dataset Language 27 eng 28
C Georeferencing Method 29 linearWithinLinearElement, pointAlongLinearElement, pointByCoordinates 30
A Dataset Documentation 31 https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/DATEX_II_Estonian_profile_Tark_Tee.pdf 32
F Related Linked Data Sources 33 34
Grade Parameter Value
F Start Date of Publication 35 36
- End Date of Publication 37 38
Grade Parameter Value
C Area Covered by Publication 39 Estonia (EE0) 40
C Network Coverage 41 National road network 42
F Network Coverage Description 43 44
Grade Parameter Value
C Transportation Modes Covered 45 Motorized traffic 46
Grade Parameter Value
B Publisher 47 Estonian Transport Administration 48
F Data Owner 49 50
Grade Parameter Value
F Contract or License 51 52
F Conditions for Use 53 54
Grade Parameter Value
F Data Format - Encoding 55 56
C Data Format - Syntax 57 XML 58
C Data Format - Grammar 59 XSD 60
A Data Format - Data Model 61 DATEX II 62
A Data Sample 63 https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/datex2_ee_mnt_safety_related_example.xml 64
A Data Schema - Validation 65 https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/datex2_ee_mnt_safety_data.xsd 66
A Data Format Description 67 DATEX II v2.3 68
B Access Interface 69 HTTP/HTTPS 70
F Security Mechanisms 71 72
C Communication Method 73 Pull 74
B Protocol Documentation 75 https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/DATEX_II_Estonian_profile_Tark_Tee.pdf 76
A Access URL 77 https://tarktee.ee/api/v1/datex/safetyData 78
Grade Parameter Value
F Update Frequency 79 80
F Availability 81 82
F Data Collection Method 83 84
F Cross Verification 85 86
F Problem Reporting Process 87 88
F Reaction Time to Respond 89 90
F Quality Description 91 92
F National Body Assessment Status 93 94
A Applicable DRs 95 Delegated Regulation (EU) No 886/2013 96

Footnotes

  1. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    Not specified.
    ↩︎
  2. Value
    https://tarktee.ee/#/en/datex
    ↩︎
  3. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    Not specified.
    ↩︎
  4. Value
    ↩︎
  5. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    Not specified.
    ↩︎
  6. Value
    Chrysostomos Mylonas
    ↩︎
  7. CMC ref.
    2.2.1.1
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  8. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  9. CMC ref.
    2.2.1.2
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  10. Value
    est; eng; rus
    Comment
    Implied by switching languages in the metadata page
    ↩︎
  11. CMC ref.
    2.2.1.3
    Obligation
    partially*
    ↩︎
  12. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  13. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  14. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  15. CMC ref.
    2.2.2.1
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  16. Value
    Important road safety data
    Comment
    Provided as expected
    ↩︎
  17. CMC ref.
    2.2.2.2
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  18. Value
    Important road safety data
    Comment
    Description is the same with the name of the dataset
    ↩︎
  19. CMC ref.
    2.2.2.3
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  20. Value (implied)
    dataset
    Comment
    Assumed
    ↩︎
  21. CMC ref.
    2.2.2.4
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  22. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  23. CMC ref.
    2.2.2.5
    Obligation
    optional
    ↩︎
  24. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  25. CMC ref.
    2.2.2.6
    Obligation
    conditionally*
    ↩︎
  26. Value
    Comment
    Non applicable
    ↩︎
  27. CMC ref.
    2.2.2.7
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  28. Value (implied)
    eng
    Comment
    Implied by the sample data
    ↩︎
  29. CMC ref.
    2.2.2.8
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  30. Value (implied)
    linearWithinLinearElement, pointAlongLinearElement, pointByCoordinates
    Comment
    Implied by the sample data
    ↩︎
  31. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  32. Value
    https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/DATEX_II_Estonian_profile_Tark_Tee.pdf
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  33. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  34. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  35. CMC ref.
    2.2.3.1
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  36. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  37. CMC ref.
    2.2.3.2
    Obligation
    optional
    ↩︎
  38. Value
    Comment
    Non applicable
    ↩︎
  39. CMC ref.
    2.2.4.1
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  40. Value (implied)
    Estonia (EE0)
    Comment
    Implied by the jurisdinction of the data provider
    ↩︎
  41. CMC ref.
    2.2.4.2
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  42. Value (implied)
    National road network
    Comment
    Implied by dataset title and description
    ↩︎
  43. CMC ref.
    2.2.4.3
    Obligation
    optional
    ↩︎
  44. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  45. CMC ref.
    2.2.5.1
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  46. Value (implied)
    Motorized traffic
    Comment
    Implied by dataset title and description
    ↩︎
  47. CMC ref.
    2.2.6.1
    Obligation
    partially*
    ↩︎
  48. Value
    Estonian Transport Administration
    Comment
    Not in the expected format (contact info is not available)
    ↩︎
  49. CMC ref.
    2.2.6.2
    Obligation
    partially*
    ↩︎
  50. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  51. CMC ref.
    2.2.7.1
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  52. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  53. CMC ref.
    2.2.7.2
    Obligation
    conditionally*
    ↩︎
  54. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  55. CMC ref.
    2.2.8.1
    Obligation
    optional
    ↩︎
  56. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  57. CMC ref.
    2.2.8.2
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  58. Value (implied)
    XML
    Comment
    Implied by the sample data
    ↩︎
  59. CMC ref.
    2.2.8.3
    Obligation
    optional
    ↩︎
  60. Value (implied)
    XSD
    Comment
    Implied by Syntax
    ↩︎
  61. CMC ref.
    2.2.8.4
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  62. Value
    DATEX II
    Comment
    Provided as expected
    ↩︎
  63. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  64. Value
    https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/datex2_ee_mnt_safety_related_example.xml
    Comment
    Provided as expected
    ↩︎
  65. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  66. Value
    https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/datex2_ee_mnt_safety_data.xsd
    Comment
    Provided as expected
    ↩︎
  67. CMC ref.
    2.2.8.5
    Obligation
    conditionally*
    ↩︎
  68. Value
    DATEX II v2.3
    Comment
    Provided as expected
    ↩︎
  69. CMC ref.
    2.2.8.6
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  70. Value
    HTTP/HTTPS
    Comment
    Not in the expected format (not explicitly mentioned)
    ↩︎
  71. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  72. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  73. CMC ref.
    2.2.8.7
    Obligation
    conditionally*
    ↩︎
  74. Value (implied)
    Pull
    Comment
    Implied by access URL
    ↩︎
  75. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  76. Value
    https://tarktee.ee/assets/datex/DATEX_II_Estonian_profile_Tark_Tee.pdf
    Comment
    Does not directly document the protocol
    ↩︎
  77. CMC ref.
    2.2.8.8
    Obligation
    conditionally*
    ↩︎
  78. Value
    https://tarktee.ee/api/v1/datex/safetyData
    Comment
    Provided as expected
    ↩︎
  79. CMC ref.
    2.2.9.1
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  80. Value
    Comment
    Mentioned within the documentation
    ↩︎
  81. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  82. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  83. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  84. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  85. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  86. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  87. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  88. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  89. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  90. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  91. CMC ref.
    2.2.9.2
    Obligation
    mandatory
    ↩︎
  92. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  93. CMC ref.
    2.2.9.3
    Obligation
    optional
    ↩︎
  94. Value
    Comment
    Not available
    ↩︎
  95. CMC ref.
    Not specified.
    Obligation
    recommended
    ↩︎
  96. Value
    Delegated Regulation (EU) No 886/2013
    Comment
    Provided as expected
    ↩︎